Monthly Archives: March 2019

慈善中医机构是福还是祸

慈善中医机构是福还是祸

医师的天职是救死扶伤,以慈悲为怀,这是放之四海而皆准的。近几年, 慈善中医机构不断地扩展,计划要把慈悲遍布全岛。这个“壮举”看似照福人群,可是却导致中医院校无人问津,同时降低了中医在社会中的地位,也无形中降低了中医的医疗水平。

首先,所谓慈善,就是要帮助低收入的家庭。可是在慈善机构里,一眼望去,看诊的患者都来自低收入的家庭吗?当然不是。然而,从逻辑上来看,如果慈善诊所有必要遍布全岛,那应该说明新加坡人多数都来自低收入家庭。可是事实并非如此。所以其实慈善机构不需要太多。

第二,不计其数的慈善机构,导致私人诊所难以经营。他们无法与廉价,甚至免费的诊所抗衡。中医其实跟西医一样,都想自己创立诊疗所,可是如今这种局面,使他们望而却步。

第三,私人诊所无法经营,刚毕业的中医师,只好投身到慈善机构。由于是慈善,工资也是“慈善的工资”。如果一个人自给自足,勉强可以过活。可是如果要养家糊口,这位中医师就会纳入低收入家庭,真叫人啼笑皆非。而且慈善诊所给予的药物,也一样是“慈善的量”,没有办法根据患者的病情而增加,造就了中医看不好病的一个大问题。

第四,一个没有前途的职业,中医院校怎么会有人问津?即使有,多数的人都是有一点本钱,无需白天工作养家糊口或者是已经在社会上驰骋了多年,由于对中医有兴趣才报读。这些学生毕业后,多数都是业余的义务医师。在当今的局面,他们很难离开目前高新的工作岗位,全职投入中医的领域。而且近年来从南阳理工大学毕业的中医师,虽然是双学位的优秀生,可是投身到中医领域的人却寥寥无几。

第五,在业余义务坐诊,虽然能增加信心,累积经验。可是多数的患者都是一些相对不威胁生命的疾病,如感冒、咳嗽、胃病和痹症等等。这些经验对于提升医疗水平,其实无大用处。西医可以“治疗”的疾病难道中医治不好吗?许多患者都不知道中医也可以治疗三高、肝硬化、肾衰竭、心脏病等等重症。中医之所以能流传至今,是因为它的临床疗效显著,许多疑难重症,皆化险为夷。

建国一代的计划,蓝卡的特惠,确实让许多低收入家庭受惠。可是他们在中医诊所里却无法得到任何回扣。医疗公积金也存在同样的问题。如果我们把局面倒过来,中医院很多,慈善西医诊所遍布全岛,中医院校还会无人问津吗?中医的社会地位还会低吗?答案是斐然的。

在没有政府的支持下,新加坡的中医真的要自强不息。目前的情况,我们还谈不上促进中医药研究和发展,而是必须考虑未来的中医栋梁,他们该何去何从,还是从此在新加坡销声匿迹。我们需要互相扶持,提升中医在社会上的地位,一个相当于西医同等的地位,才是当务之急。

综上所述,真的有必要扩展慈善中医机构吗?拓展慈善的伟人,你考虑到中医界的存亡吗?唉。。。

 

Be our own

I do not want to be merely an appendix to someone else’s destiny. Everyone has a capacity to love and feel, and I feel that nothing should stop us be our own people.

I learnt that from family. It is often the case where children, when they can afford it, reward parents with the trip of the lifetime, but most often in their terms. However, having being exposed in cross-cultural settings, I learnt there is more than just doing things out of what you think you like.

Respect is two-way traffic. You do actually want people to not just treat you well, but allow you the space to be what is you. In Asia, for parents, it means giving parents the opportunity to decide what are the terms they want to feel the love.

It is easy to say: I want to bring you to Taiwan, and then maybe the parents just go around Taiwan. If that’s the case, I believe my parents would have visited Taiwan multiple times. i intuitively felt, based on my understanding on the mere occasions my parents traveled since my parents and my sisters went for their last trip together, that it has to be a trip that my parents decide on their terms. All of the trips thus far are TCM-related trips where it involves a TCM meeting on paediatric medicine.

Just because I am the only sibling close to my parents (and for that, a circumstance I will like to explain in detail when I am even-minded to explain with factual and observational clarity) doesn’t mean I know more about my parents. However, I know for sure, my siblings just do not see my parents as full working professionals, the way that they want to present themselves to us and our children. For this, I prefer silence and I do not want to engage with my siblings. If they are unsupportive of my parents the way they want to ‘get’, then I believe they should not have a piece of my parents’ legacy – which, unfortunately, they will get. It all begins when I see my parents being slighted.

If society is not discriminatory of me and people like me, which I do consider as the biggest consideration in my life, I am willing to do anything and everything ahead of me.

Is TCM any inferior to other worthy professions? TCM is more difficult than many other professions out there, which are difficult. Do consider, though, TCM is the combination of life sciences, traditional Chinese philosophy, and our understanding of our land, air and time.

I believe the world, including the half-baked Singapore autistic and autism communities, need to open eyes to see new possibilities in TCM. The family is indeed the most critical of autistic success, the parents have to strike a balance between letting the autistic make individual great decisions and contribute fully to society, as well as giving him the time, resources and heart to empower the autistic individual. The parents must not set the agenda, for this is a surefire way of failure in the life of autistic people.